Spanning Multiple Seasons or entire Careers, From 1871 to 2012, Younger than 31, Hall Of Fame Members (as mlb players), sorted by greatest WAR for Pitchers: Results

generated by a site user

This report was generated using the SHARE link located just above the stat tables on the site. Give it a try!

User's Notes:
Rk Player WAR From To Age G GS CG SHO GF W L W-L% SV IP H R ER BB SO ERA ERA HR BF IBB HBP BK WP Tm
1 Walter Johnson 119.9 1907 1919 19-31 544 439 388 86 99 297 191 .609 22 4090.2 3145 1103 749 818 2614 1.65 172 31 15736 142 3 129 WSH
2 Kid Nichols 108.5 1890 1901 20-31 557 502 476 44 53 329 183 .643 16 4549.0 4451 2273 1515 1163 1680 3.00 143 151 18977 118 1 156 BSN
3 Christy Mathewson 89.4 1900 1912 19-31 515 451 365 68 57 312 146 .681 24 3910.0 3341 1261 862 776 2258 1.98 147 52 15400 56 8 103 NYG
4 John Clarkson 82.9 1882 1893 20-31 509 500 472 36 9 320 168 .656 5 4385.2 4122 2275 1343 1145 1950 2.76 133 153 18493 80 0 174 WOR-CHC-BSN-TOT-CLV
5 Cy Young 81.6 1890 1898 23-31 420 369 346 24 48 241 135 .641 7 3353.0 3487 1731 1155 724 1014 3.10 138 77 14089 79 0 89 CLV
6 Pud Galvin 76.9 1875 1888 18-31 581 569 542 50 15 305 255 .545 2 5010.2 5276 2689 1500 502 1593 2.69 110 86 21045 26 2 193 STL-BUF-TOT-PIT
7 Tim Keefe 73.7 1880 1888 23-31 443 442 431 33 2 263 167 .612 0 3832.0 3261 1732 1017 758 1994 2.39 131 50 15599 38 0 197 TRO-NYP-NYG
8 Tom Seaver 71.1 1967 1976 22-31 354 348 161 39 5 182 107 .630 1 2718.2 2151 816 747 733 2334 2.47 141 187 10839 62 48 6 68 NYM
9 Amos Rusie 68.6 1889 1901 18-30 463 427 393 30 35 246 174 .586 5 3778.2 3389 2068 1288 1707 1950 3.07 129 75 16313 112 1 153 IND-NYG-CIN
10 Bert Blyleven 65.2 1970 1982 19-31 411 406 159 42 3 169 150 .530 0 3021.0 2715 1117 995 821 2376 2.96 126 217 12362 49 75 13 66 MIN-TOT-TEX-PIT-CLE
11 Robin Roberts 64.5 1948 1958 21-31 433 386 238 31 38 206 156 .569 23 3127.2 2984 1256 1133 626 1558 3.26 120 318 12725 27 33 0 23 PHI
12 Mickey Welch 64.2 1880 1891 20-31 564 548 525 41 16 307 210 .594 4 4797.0 4577 2547 1439 1293 1849 2.70 114 106 20278 52 1 274 TRO-NYG
13 Bob Feller 61.9 1936 1950 17-31 419 363 229 37 42 208 123 .628 20 2929.0 2389 1120 1004 1433 2227 3.09 131 146 12356 43 10 65 CLE
14 Don Drysdale 61.4 1956 1968 19-31 506 453 166 48 34 204 162 .557 6 3369.1 3013 1258 1093 842 2462 2.92 122 271 13830 123 152 10 81 BRO-LAD
15 Pete Alexander 61.4 1911 1918 24-31 332 280 222 61 47 192 89 .683 15 2518.0 2120 795 593 558 1418 2.12 144 46 9985 55 1 19 PHI-CHC
16 Ed Walsh 60.5 1904 1912 23-31 397 289 236 54 98 182 118 .607 34 2773.2 2177 801 544 539 1668 1.77 149 22 10622 46 8 67 CHW
17 Hal Newhouser 59.9 1939 1952 18-31 453 369 212 33 63 200 147 .576 18 2922.1 2608 1159 986 1219 1764 3.04 131 129 12347 17 7 63 DET
18 Vic Willis 58.8 1898 1907 22-31 400 375 327 38 24 195 171 .533 7 3189.2 2915 1328 946 999 1392 2.67 121 55 13049 145 6 83 BSN-PIT
19 Rube Waddell 57.8 1897 1908 20-31 366 310 245 45 45 179 128 .583 4 2708.0 2225 966 640 735 2159 2.13 139 35 10748 107 3 71 LOU-PIT-TOT-PHA-SLB
20 Old Hoss Radbourn 56.7 1881 1886 26-31 353 335 329 29 17 220 119 .649 3 3057.1 2766 1375 724 463 1446 2.13 136 54 12511 0 166 PRO-BSN
21 Fergie Jenkins 56.7 1965 1974 22-31 383 325 178 33 30 174 121 .590 7 2632.0 2301 1002 903 534 2045 3.09 123 262 10624 74 49 10 36 PHI-TOT-CHC-TEX
22 Juan Marichal 55.2 1960 1969 22-31 328 320 197 45 8 191 88 .685 2 2549.2 2161 861 728 503 1840 2.57 136 223 10212 57 30 13 37 SFG
23 Sandy Koufax 53.1 1955 1966 19-30 397 314 137 40 44 165 87 .655 9 2324.1 1754 806 713 817 2396 2.76 131 204 9497 48 18 7 87 BRO-LAD
24 Jim Palmer 52.6 1965 1977 19-31 386 360 168 45 10 194 104 .651 3 2823.2 2301 921 830 952 1722 2.65 132 197 11446 33 28 7 69 BAL
25 Lefty Grove 48.5 1925 1931 25-31 313 209 131 14 77 146 61 .705 38 1834.0 1713 715 578 578 1221 2.84 153 59 7669 23 1 35 PHA
Rk Player WAR From To Age G GS CG SHO GF W L W-L% SV IP H R ER BB SO ERA ERA HR BF IBB HBP BK WP Tm
26 Steve Carlton 46.1 1965 1976 20-31 382 364 158 33 7 168 126 .571 1 2704.0 2409 1054 932 961 2111 3.10 117 199 11242 77 29 18 91 STL-PHI
27 Addie Joss 45.9 1902 1910 22-30 286 260 234 45 22 160 97 .623 5 2327.0 1888 730 488 364 920 1.89 142 19 8891 58 1 28 CLE
28 Dennis Eckersley 45.6 1975 1986 20-31 376 359 100 20 8 151 128 .541 3 2496.0 2401 1101 1018 624 1627 3.67 111 268 10398 65 56 14 24 CLE-BOS-TOT-CHC
29 Eddie Plank 43.9 1901 1907 25-31 266 253 218 29 11 153 95 .617 0 2156.0 1943 810 605 491 1075 2.53 118 24 8661 123 1 46 PHA
30 Lefty Gomez 42.9 1930 1940 21-31 331 283 163 26 31 168 92 .646 9 2262.0 2068 969 824 922 1351 3.28 129 124 9639 16 0 33 NYY
31 Dizzy Dean 42.4 1930 1941 20-31 316 229 154 26 76 150 83 .644 30 1963.1 1916 774 661 452 1163 3.03 130 95 8157 27 5 12 STL-CHC
32 Stan Coveleski 42.3 1912 1921 22-31 260 210 140 22 42 129 80 .617 16 1778.1 1639 623 507 441 655 2.57 133 25 7153 20 1 20 PHA-CLE
33 Chief Bender 42.2 1903 1915 19-31 411 311 243 36 87 197 118 .625 29 2780.1 2423 1011 749 651 1625 2.42 114 35 10915 85 10 71 PHA-BAL
34 Warren Spahn 40.0 1942 1952 21-31 262 236 142 27 22 122 91 .573 9 1884.0 1686 731 637 587 1000 3.04 124 128 7785 14 1 37 BSN
35 Nolan Ryan 39.3 1966 1978 19-31 362 328 152 37 13 151 145 .510 3 2468.2 1720 973 857 1532 2686 3.12 111 134 10467 39 74 11 116 NYM-CAL
36 Waite Hoyt 39.0 1918 1931 18-31 459 344 190 21 91 189 131 .591 33 2838.2 3057 1368 1160 816 853 3.68 110 114 12116 37 3 32 NYG-BOS-NYY-TOT
37 Carl Hubbell 37.3 1928 1934 25-31 266 211 134 24 46 121 76 .614 22 1787.1 1666 650 542 337 826 2.73 144 92 7300 33 1 20 NYG
38 Ted Lyons 36.6 1923 1932 22-31 344 252 182 13 76 140 123 .532 21 2221.2 2385 1091 898 648 485 3.64 115 81 9490 15 4 24 CHW
39 Don Sutton 36.6 1966 1976 21-31 402 387 125 44 10 176 136 .564 3 2812.0 2401 1039 946 735 2074 3.03 110 209 11458 65 50 10 69 LAD
40 Catfish Hunter 35.7 1965 1977 19-31 460 437 175 41 5 210 151 .582 1 3226.1 2732 1263 1139 885 1922 3.18 106 343 13095 57 47 7 45 KCA-OAK-NYY
41 Rich Gossage 34.7 1972 1983 20-31 568 37 16 0 401 81 73 .526 206 1236.1 988 440 392 519 1076 2.85 133 74 5117 62 30 1 40 CHW-PIT-NYY
42 Gaylord Perry 34.7 1962 1970 23-31 330 246 111 19 30 118 97 .549 10 2014.1 1806 776 669 514 1448 2.99 118 145 8268 85 45 2 73 SFG
43 Bob Gibson 34.3 1959 1967 23-31 280 242 110 25 17 125 88 .587 4 1904.0 1612 749 660 704 1582 3.12 124 147 7949 48 59 4 61 STL
44 Jack Chesbro 33.2 1899 1905 25-31 258 229 197 27 25 151 80 .654 3 2021.1 1788 800 567 485 891 2.52 122 28 8097 80 2 41 PIT-NYY
45 Red Ruffing 31.8 1924 1936 19-31 429 343 207 21 69 152 170 .472 16 2800.1 2822 1481 1278 1086 1343 4.11 102 148 12126 47 5 36 BOS-TOT-NYY
46 Joe McGinnity 30.4 1899 1902 28-31 184 160 144 7 23 103 62 .624 3 1443.0 1461 714 483 380 348 3.01 124 19 6064 104 3 14 BLN-BRO-BLA-TOT
47 Mordecai Brown 29.8 1903 1908 26-31 196 161 138 33 34 117 56 .676 12 1485.0 1197 439 281 303 627 1.70 158 15 5720 28 2 25 STL-CHC
48 Herb Pennock 29.7 1912 1925 18-31 363 241 149 23 84 133 104 .561 19 2108.0 2165 943 804 632 793 3.43 108 70 8793 26 3 38 PHA-TOT-BOS-NYY
49 Jim Bunning 29.5 1955 1963 23-31 304 251 78 16 27 118 87 .576 12 1867.1 1692 796 715 564 1406 3.45 116 223 7815 31 73 5 26 DET
50 Monte Ward 28.5 1878 1884 18-24 293 262 245 24 32 164 103 .614 3 2469.2 2324 1185 576 253 920 2.10 119 26 10164 0 144 PRO-NYG
Rk Player WAR From To Age G GS CG SHO GF W L W-L% SV IP H R ER BB SO ERA ERA HR BF IBB HBP BK WP Tm
51 Whitey Ford 28.4 1950 1960 21-31 278 237 102 28 24 133 59 .693 7 1754.1 1469 607 527 729 1000 2.70 137 115 7252 26 18 5 37 NYY
52 Burleigh Grimes 26.0 1916 1925 22-31 331 280 199 20 43 151 127 .543 5 2440.1 2535 1181 929 736 980 3.43 103 78 10434 57 8 64 PIT-BRO
53 Rube Marquard 25.6 1908 1918 21-31 352 270 147 24 54 146 114 .562 18 2247.1 2049 885 678 592 1223 2.72 108 63 9112 28 3 62 NYG-TOT-BRO
54 Eppa Rixey 25.5 1912 1922 21-31 332 272 157 18 37 131 134 .494 7 2218.1 2179 956 720 590 846 2.92 111 34 9190 41 8 67 PHI-CIN
55 Bruce Sutter 24.8 1976 1984 23-31 549 0 0 0 425 58 60 .492 260 889.2 722 289 251 260 753 2.54 152 57 3597 74 9 8 37 CHC-STL
56 Bob Lemon 22.7 1946 1952 25-31 277 197 116 22 56 119 70 .630 16 1695.2 1430 680 587 806 822 3.12 123 100 7155 23 1 32 CLE
57 Babe Ruth 20.5 1914 1921 19-26 161 145 105 17 12 92 46 .667 4 1203.1 951 392 301 436 485 2.25 123 10 4815 29 4 25 BOS-NYY
58 Red Faber 18.8 1914 1920 25-31 242 173 105 13 53 105 68 .607 12 1496.1 1396 605 424 465 620 2.55 119 26 6040 50 2 21 CHW
59 Phil Niekro 16.9 1964 1970 25-31 236 122 56 13 61 66 58 .532 20 1117.2 985 438 362 281 704 2.92 122 96 4583 23 29 6 69 MLN-ATL
60 Early Wynn 16.8 1939 1951 19-31 286 253 133 14 30 121 115 .513 3 1919.1 1938 929 798 725 724 3.74 100 110 8279 23 2 19 WSH-CLE
61 Rollie Fingers 16.8 1968 1978 21-31 647 37 4 2 469 81 83 .494 208 1255.2 1067 455 402 358 969 2.88 118 91 5093 71 36 4 25 OAK-SDP
62 Jesse Haines 11.4 1918 1925 24-31 215 184 97 10 20 83 87 .488 2 1429.2 1568 722 580 375 473 3.65 102 66 6093 32 3 23 CIN-STL
63 Hoyt Wilhelm 9.7 1952 1954 29-31 196 0 0 0 101 34 15 .694 33 415.2 331 153 118 186 243 2.55 158 30 1730 14 1 14 NYG
64 Bobby Wallace 6.0 1894 1902 20-28 57 48 37 3 9 24 22 .522 1 402.0 469 268 173 156 120 3.87 125 6 1799 13 0 16 CLV-SLB
65 Dazzy Vance 3.2 1915 1922 24-31 47 35 17 5 9 18 16 .529 0 278.2 294 144 119 117 152 3.84 104 10 1215 11 0 6 TOT-NYY-BRO
66 George Sisler 2.2 1915 1920 22-27 21 12 9 1 5 5 6 .455 2 106.0 90 36 29 48 59 2.46 118 0 436 6 1 2 SLB
67 Roger Bresnahan 0.9 1897 1910 18-31 9 6 3 1 3 4 1 .800 0 50.1 68 30 22 15 15 3.93 108 1 230 3 0 0 WHS-BLA-STL
68 High Pockets Kelly 0.3 1917 1917 21-21 1 0 0 0 1 1 0 1.000 0 5.0 4 0 0 1 2 0.00 0 20 0 0 0 NYG
69 Jimmie Foxx 0.1 1939 1939 31-31 1 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 1.0 0 0 0 0 1 0.00 0 3 0 0 0 BOS
70 Sam Rice 0.1 1915 1916 25-26 9 3 1 0 4 1 1 .500 0 39.1 31 18 11 19 12 2.52 117 0 156 0 0 1 WSH
71 Harry Hooper 0.1 1913 1913 25-25 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2.0 2 0 0 1 0 0.00 0 7 0 0 0 BOS
72 Cap Anson 0.1 1883 1883 31-31 2 0 0 0 2 0 0 1 3.0 1 1 0 1 0 0.00 0 12 0 0 CHC
73 Deacon White 0.1 1876 1876 28-28 1 0 0 0 1 0 0 1 2.0 1 0 0 0 3 0.00 0 7 0 CHC
74 Buck Ewing 0.0 1882 1890 22-30 9 4 4 0 4 2 3 .400 0 47.0 55 36 18 23 23 3.45 112 2 233 1 0 3 TRO-NYG-NYI
75 Ted Williams 0.0 1940 1940 21-21 1 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 2.0 3 1 1 0 1 4.50 116 0 9 0 0 0 BOS
Rk Player WAR From To Age G GS CG SHO GF W L W-L% SV IP H R ER BB SO ERA ERA HR BF IBB HBP BK WP Tm
76 Ty Cobb 0.0 1918 1918 31-31 2 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 4.0 6 2 2 2 0 4.50 67 0 17 0 0 0 DET
77 Tris Speaker -0.1 1914 1914 26-26 1 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 1.0 2 1 1 0 0 9.00 47 0 4 0 0 0 BOS
78 Honus Wagner -0.1 1900 1902 26-28 2 0 0 0 2 0 0 0 8.1 7 5 0 6 6 0.00 0 37 0 0 3 PIT
79 George Davis -0.4 1891 1891 20-20 3 0 0 0 3 0 1 .000 1 4.0 8 8 7 3 4 15.75 24 0 23 0 0 0 CLV
80 King Kelly -0.8 1880 1887 22-29 7 0 0 0 5 1 1 .500 0 22.1 33 29 10 17 2 4.03 94 3 119 0 0 7 CHC-BSN
81 Dan Brouthers -1.1 1879 1883 21-25 4 2 2 0 1 0 2 .000 0 23.0 44 37 20 11 8 7.83 35 0 127 0 4 TRO-BUF
82 Tommy McCarthy -1.5 1884 1894 20-30 13 7 5 0 7 0 8 .000 0 70.1 85 65 39 26 21 4.99 67 3 328 0 0 12 BOS-PHI-STL-BSN
83 Jesse Burkett -2.7 1890 1894 21-25 22 14 6 0 8 3 10 .231 0 122.0 140 125 75 93 82 5.53 63 3 609 14 0 16 NYG-CLV
84 Stan Musial 1952 1952 31-31 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.0 0 0 0 0 0 undef 0 1 0 0 0 STL
Provided by Baseball-Reference.com: View Play Index Tool Used
Generated 3/29/2013.

Please report any abuse.